The Monstrous and the Marvelous
By Rikki Ducornet
Literary Criticism. With the great Renaissance voyages to the New World came the popularity of Wunderkammern, or cabinets of wonders, in which newly discovered monsters and marvels could be displayed. Like such a cabinet, this collection of essays surveys the monstrous and the marvelous -- as transmuted in the alembic of Rikki Ducornet's open-hearted vision -- in literature, art and film. For her, excess anomaly, and heterodoxy entice the imagining mind to embrace "otherness," enlarge the world, and regenerate Eden.
Review
"We need writers to look at difficult issues in a sophisticated manner. Ducornet has done this. She is a mirror of our innermost selves and she gives us back to ourselves. Despairing, hopeful, active, contemplative, fractured but surviving, playful, even happy sometimes (in our case), whole!" -- The Nation
Provocative, Difficult and Disturbing Essays
Rikki Ducornet's "The Monstrous and the Marvelous" is a collection of fourteen previously published essays that challenge comfortable intellectual and imaginative categories, forcing the reader to think in new ways, to embrace the savage, eccentric and strange beauty of the world in all its "Otherness". It is, in short, a book not for the intellectually faint of heart, Ducornet's richly allusive prose streaming through interpretive tropes that constantly demand the reader's utmost attention and imaginative empathy. And while this wide-ranging collection appropriately has been compared to a kind of intellectual "wunderkammern" or "cabinet of wonders", Ducornet imaginatively demonstrates in these essays that the world cannot be contained within the artificial bounds of the "wunderkammern", for ultimately its contents are "topsy turvy and promiscuous."
In the essay "Optical Terror", Ducornet sets the stage for the essays to follow, discussing the great Renaissance voyages of discovery, voyages "which revealed a sprawling world, infinitely stranger than previously imagined." The curiosities that came from these voyages, the stuff of the "wunderkammern", challenged accepted notions of the world, generating the intellectual unease which ultimately led to the Enlightenment. In Ducornet's words, "the fantastic influx of curiosities had a profoundly unsettling effect upon pedestrian and pious minds persuaded that the finite world was created reasonably, to the measure of man and for his salvation."
From "Optical Terror", Ducornet goes on to develop the trope of the "wunderkammern" through the diversely imagined and imaginative essays of "The Monstrous and the Marvelous". Thus, she ranges from a stunningly imaginative essay connecting Kafka and Borges ("Alphabets and Emperors: Reflections on Kafka and Borges") to a short essay on Rosamond Purcell's studies on human monstrosities and anomalies ("The Impossible Genus") to an essay on stories of haruspication or divination by the inspection of animal entrails ("Sortilege"). There is a strangely imagined, intellectually difficult and scatologically-driven essay on Swift which bears the imprint of the excessive envisionings of Georges Bataille, and there is a quirkily dark essay exploring the lethal female body in Pasolini, David Lynch, Robert Coover, and Angela Carter.
Intellectually provocative, and at times deeply disturbing, the essays strive to reorder the way we see and, ultimately, the way we articulate and dream, the world. The essays transgress the boundaries of the reader's imagination, often going beyond the point of comprehension, and this is perhaps Ducornet's only weakness: the imaginative flights of imagination are so startling and, at times, abstruse that the reader struggles with her metaphors, her tropes, her meanings. But while imperfect, there is a scent of genius in "The Monstrous and the Marvelous", a scent which is worth taking the time to savor.
Provocative, Difficult and Disturbing Essays
Rikki Ducornet's "The Monstrous and the Marvelous" is a collection of fourteen previously published essays that challenge comfortable intellectual and imaginative categories, forcing the reader to think in new ways, to embrace the savage, eccentric and strange beauty of the world in all its "Otherness". It is, in short, a book not for the intellectually faint of heart, Ducornet's richly allusive prose streaming through interpretive tropes that constantly demand the reader's utmost attention and imaginative empathy. And while this wide-ranging collection appropriately has been compared to a kind of intellectual "wunderkammern" or "cabinet of wonders", Ducornet imaginatively demonstrates in these essays that the world cannot be contained within the artificial bounds of the "wunderkammern", for ultimately its contents are "topsy turvy and promiscuous."
In the essay "Optical Terror", Ducornet sets the stage for the essays to follow, discussing the great Renaissance voyages of discovery, voyages "which revealed a sprawling world, infinitely stranger than previously imagined." The curiosities that came from these voyages, the stuff of the "wunderkammern", challenged accepted notions of the world, generating the intellectual unease which ultimately led to the Enlightenment. In Ducornet's words, "the fantastic influx of curiosities had a profoundly unsettling effect upon pedestrian and pious minds persuaded that the finite world was created reasonably, to the measure of man and for his salvation."
From "Optical Terror", Ducornet goes on to develop the trope of the "wunderkammern" through the diversely imagined and imaginative essays of "The Monstrous and the Marvelous". Thus, she ranges from a stunningly imaginative essay connecting Kafka and Borges ("Alphabets and Emperors: Reflections on Kafka and Borges") to a short essay on Rosamond Purcell's studies on human monstrosities and anomalies ("The Impossible Genus") to an essay on stories of haruspication or divination by the inspection of animal entrails ("Sortilege"). There is a strangely imagined, intellectually difficult and scatologically-driven essay on Swift which bears the imprint of the excessive envisionings of Georges Bataille, and there is a quirkily dark essay exploring the lethal female body in Pasolini, David Lynch, Robert Coover, and Angela Carter.
Intellectually provocative, and at times deeply disturbing, the essays strive to reorder the way we see and, ultimately, the way we articulate and dream, the world. The essays transgress the boundaries of the reader's imagination, often going beyond the point of comprehension, and this is perhaps Ducornet's only weakness: the imaginative flights of imagination are so startling and, at times, abstruse that the reader struggles with her metaphors, her tropes, her meanings. But while imperfect, there is a scent of genius in "The Monstrous and the Marvelous", a scent which is worth taking the time to savor.
The Monstrous and the Marvelous is simply Marvelous
From the Swift essay to the Borges-Kafka essay and much inbetween, this thin collection bursts with vitality and insight. Far from being difficult or flawed as one reviewer has suggested, this collection is near perfect. It deals with the beautifully strange in all of its permutations. I've not so enjoyed a nonfiction collection since reading Angela Carter's nonfiction.