Race Results: Hollywood vs the Supreme Court; Ten Decades of Racial Decisions and Film
By Eileen C. Moore
Author Eileen Moore, a California Appellate Court Justice brings a decade-by-decade comparison of Hollywood films and Supreme Court decisions, and then shows how this affected our lives. Beginning with The Birth of a Nation in 1915 and continuing on through the new millennium, a surprising fact is that the United States Supreme Court, often perceived as out-of-touch and stuffy, is often far more fair and liberal in their treatment of blacks than is Hollywood. Offset beautifully by more than twenty black and white photos, this in-depth study is sometimes shocking, often surprising, and is a must-read for anyone interested in the history of film, law, race relations, pop culture . . . even our country.
About the Author
Author Eileen Comerford Moore was born and raised in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. She worked as a registered nurse for seven years, including serving as a combat nurse in Vietnam. She is a life member of Vietnam Veterans of America and has kept her nursing license active so she doesn t forget her roots. She graduated Cum Laude from the University of California Irvine in 1975, then pursued the study of law and graduated from Pepperdine University School of Law in 1978. She received a Masters degree from the University of Virginia in 2004. Moore has been a Justice on the California Court of Appeal since 2000. From 1989 to 2000, she was a judge on the California Superior Court.
Think about Race Results!
While enjoying reading Race Results by Eileen C. Moore, one will inevitably reflect on interplays among powerful partners in American society. Justice Moore thoughtfully compares and creatively contrasts Supreme Court decisions and Hollywood movies and their contributions to, and against, civil rights and racial equality. While reading how the Supreme Court, which most think is more "conservative" than the movie industry, is actually more "liberal" than Hollywood, I kept thinking about two formative institutions in my own life: The Episcopal Church and Major League Baseball. The Episcopal Church included African Americans such as The Rev'd Absalom Jones and his congregation in Philadelphia as equals as early as 1795; and, of course, the great Jack Roosevelt "Jackie" Robinson broke modern major league baseball's color line when he debuted with the Dodgers in 1947. Race Results will get you thinking!
Lights, Camera, Action!
In a spacious layout of 280 pages of text and photographs - with an additional 22 pages of interesting endnotes - Eileen C. Moore successfully tackles the exploration of race in major movies and court decisions in Race Results: Hollywood vs. the Supreme Court; Ten Decades of Racial Decisions and Film (October 2009, Cool Titles).
Moore, an Associate Justice in the Fourth District, Division Three Court of Appeal for the State of California, packs a wealth of information in chapters split into decades - from 1901-1910 to 2001-2009 - while providing an intriguing crossover appeal to readers interested in federal law, social history or pop culture. And due to the cinema available, Moore centers her work on Academy Award winners for Best Picture of the Year, the American Film Institute's Top 100 American Films, movies directed by Sir Alfred Hitchcock, KBE ("because his films span several decades") and other films of relevance.
"The Court is often considered the most conservative in the country, and Hollywood has always been perceived as being quite liberal," Moore writes. "I devised the idea of comparing the two, decade-by-decade, to see just what legal and cultural messages each was sending to the American people."
But initial glances can be deceiving, according to Moore: "After the first few decades of the twentieth century and throughout the rest of the century, the United States Supreme Court was consistently more progressive than Hollywood in its treatment of African Americans.
"On the other hand, the film industry committed itself to its bottom line. Equality, humanity and basic fairness toward blacks were mostly ignored. The American institution most often branded as too liberal, Hollywood, was actually quite backward with its negative, and often racist, portrayals of blacks in movies."
Titans of the silver screen - D.W. Griffith, Louis B. Mayer, Jack Warner, Elia Kazan, Francis Ford Coppola, Steven Spielberg - are juxtaposed with a brief history of slavery and race relations and profiles of many major players on the national stage. There are a number of neat gems pulled from the movies, with some of the most pointed commentary by Moore reserved for The Birth of a Nation and Gone With the Wind.
"When another white woman is in danger at the hands of a black man (in The Birth of a Nation), the camera shows columns of Ku Klux Klan riding to her rescue. They gallantly charge through a black mob, shooting and mowing down as many as they can. One can only imagine the emotional level of the film's 1915 audience as the Ku Klux Klan saved the day," she writes. "Not surprisingly, Adolf Hitler, who believed the wrong side won the Civil War, loved the movie (Gone With the Wind, 1939)."
The winding road for Hitchcock travels from the 1920s to Family Plot (1976), his final theatrical release. The 1970s is an incredible time for cinema, as Blaxploitation releases (Cotton Comes to Harlem, Shaft) share top billing with successful films from a variety of genres (Rocky, Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope, Close Encounters of the Third Kind, Dirty Harry, Kramer vs. Kramer). And by mid-decade, another type of director was yelling, "It's a wrap," as the curtain closed on the House (of Representatives) Committee on Un-American Activities, with the nearly 40-year run ending in 1975.
"Hollywood steered away from showing sympathy to the civil rights movement after World War II because it feared accusations of having Communist sympathies," writes Moore. "Hollywood continued to portray backs in a harmful way through the end of the twentieth century, though its methods became more subtle as the century grew to a close.
"But as all America turns the racial page, Hollywood has little choice but to get in step."
Wonderful!
I wasn't sure what to expect but it certainly was not this eye opening book. The author of Race Results, a California Appellate Justice, says you will never watch a movie the same way again and that is so true. She shows how Hollywood specifically used racial themes through its films, including those made by Alfred Hitchcock. She is right, but who knew? I also loved the photos, which are great visuals for the points the author makes. It is not often that I finish a book, put it down, then pick it up again to check out a point. Race Results is one of those books. I'll be thinking about this topic for a long time to come.